Youngstown

Best Italian Restaurants in Youngstown

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Youngstown? We've gathered 40 spots serving Italian food in Youngstown, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Youngstown

Aqua Pazzo

Scarsella's Restaurant

Marinos Italian Restaurant

Belleria Pizza and Italian

Johnny's

MVR Restaurant Youngstown Ohio

Carmella's Café

Antone's Kitchen

Gia's Pizzeria

Belleria Pizza and Italian

V2 Wine Bar and Trattoria

Roberto's Italian Ristorante

Prima Cucina Italiana

Bistro 1907

Cafe Cimmento

MVR

Cassese's MVR

University Pizzeria & Italian Eatery

Inner Circle Pizza-ysu

Joe Restaurant

Golden Dawn Restaurant

Yosteria

Osteria

Papa Gege's Italian Villa

Nicolinni's Ristorante

Rotelli Pizza & Pasta

Bruno's Restaurant & Catering

Belleria Pizza

Antone's

Jimmy's Italian Bakery and Deli

Antone's Italian Cafe

Nonni's Ristorante

Station Square Ristorante

CA's Italian Grille and Pub

The Rainbow Inn

Belleria Pizza Wick

Belleria Pizzeria

Michael Alberini's Restaurant

Salvatore's Italian Grill

Marino's Italian Cafe

Discover

For restaurants

Company