Eatarian discovery

55 Best Restaurants in West Islip (2026)

We track 55 restaurants in West Islip on Eatarian, from neighbourhood favourites to standout dining rooms. Cuisines here include Eggs, Breakfast & Brunch in West Islip, NY, Global Wraps, Bowls & Fresh Flavors and Summerwind – Fresh Seafood, Steak & American Fare in West Islip, NY. Many are ranked by real diner ratings, with 15 on this page carrying public review scores. Reserve a free table or order direct — no booking fees, ever.