Toms River

Best Pizza Restaurants in Toms River

Looking for the best Pizza restaurants in Toms River? We've gathered 55 spots serving Pizza food in Toms River, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Pizza Restaurants in Toms River

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza

Naples Pizza and Restaurant

Papa Johns Pizza

Al's Famous Pizza

Pies On 37

Joey D's Pizza

Picasso's II Pizza and Italian

Mellow Mushroom

Holiday City Pizza

Sbarro

Attilio's Pizzeria

Slice House

La Famiglia

Lisa Pizza and Restaurant

Sal & Jimmy's Pizza

Cathy's Ristorante

The Real Pizza

Pizza and Panini

Sunrise Pizzeria

Domino's

Pondrelli's Pizza & Kitchen

Capone's Gourmet Pizza & Pasta

Marie's Pizza

Nino's Coal Fired Pizza

Lorenzo's Pizza and Restaurant

Geno D's Pizza & Subs

Frankie G's Pizza

Via Roma Pizza and Restaurant

Domino's

The Spot Pizza Grill

Papa John's Pizza

Charlie's Pizza

Antonio's Italian Restaurant

Mia's Pizza 37

Giampapa's Pizzeria

Floyd's Brick Oven Pizza

Donato's Pizza

Donato's Pizza

The Little Gym of Toms River, NJ

Charlie's Pizza

Linda's Pizza

Little Mia's Pizza

DiCosmo's Pizza

Steverinos pizza

Steverino's Pizzeria

Villaggio Pizza Toms River

Cuzzins Pizza Toms River N.J.

Veraces Pizza

Discover

For restaurants

Company