Staten Island

Best Italian Restaurants in Staten Island

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Staten Island? We've gathered 105 spots serving Italian food in Staten Island, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Staten Island

Osteria By Primo

Italian Touch Pizza & Pasta

Il Sapore Cafe

Nino's Restaurant

Max's Es-Ca

Casa Verde Restaurant

Cucina Fresca

The Manor

Patrizia's Of Tottenville

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn

Eatitalian Nyc

Rossville Pizza

Domenico's Pizza & Pasta

Bruzzese's Italian Gourmet

Il Pallino

Zio Toto

Millie's of Staten Island

San Marco Ristorante Italiano

Il Sogno Ristorante Italiano

Vitalia

Angelina's

Osfizio

La Stanza

Nove Italian Bistro

Corrado's Cucina

Freddies

Gios Restaurant

Sapori Ristorante

Patrizia's Pizza and Pasta

Patrizia's of Staten Island

Zena's Italian Tapas & Lounge

Mona Lisa Pizzeria

Trattoria Toscana

puglia's of Hester Street

Piezanos

Dolce Fantasia 2

Portobello Cafe

La Riviera

Fornelletto Pizza and Restaurant

Lorenzo's Restaurant

Casanova

Da Noi

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Amici Brick Oven Pizza

Capizzi

Giuliana's Restaurant

Trattoria Amici

Anthony's Paninoteca