Newark

Best Italian Restaurants in Newark

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Newark? We've gathered 43 spots serving Italian food in Newark, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Newark

La Casa Pasta Restaurant

Campanella

Pounder's Pizza

Adornetto's Selected Italian Food

Margherita's Pizza

Taverna

Caffe Gelato Restaurant

Tony's Cafe

Evero Spezia

Soffritto Italian Grill

Tony's Bistro

Rudys Family Restaurant & Pizzeria - Newark Italian Restaurant

La Casa Pasta Restaurant

Ciao Pizza & Pasta

Olive Grill

Bertucci's Italian Restaurant

Nonna

Limoncello Italian Grill

Salute Bistro & Bar

Olive Garden

Squisito Pizza and Pasta

Villa italian kitchen

Nonna's Kitchen & Bar

Nonna's Meatball Kitchen

Tagliare

Salumeria Prima

Tj's Italian Style Hot Dogs & Sausages

Worlds First Italian Style Hot

Luigi's Caffe

Luigi's Italian Tradition

Michael Angelo's Restaurant

The Original Pizzarama

Sugo - Taste the Sauce

Portici italian taste experience

Suite 304 Bar & Restaurant

Giovanni Pizza Pasta & Grill

Annabella's Kitchen

Fresh Coast

Mercato Tomato Pie

Il Pomodoro

The Monk Room

Assaggini di Roma

Five Corners Ristorante