New Haven

Best Pizza Restaurants in New Haven

Looking for the best Pizza restaurants in New Haven? We've gathered 91 spots serving Pizza food in New Haven, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Pizza Restaurants in New Haven

Amity Brick Oven Pizza

Liberty Pizza

USA 1 Pizza

Avelino's Pizza

Hunt Brothers Pizza

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

Mancino's of New Haven

Pizza Hut

Papa John's Pizza

Pizza King

Papa Johns Pizza

Papa John's Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza

Domino's

Hungry Howie's Pizza

Spooner's Pizza

Barbarossa Pizza Kebabs (formerly Snoopers Pizza)

Amity Pizza

Clemente's Pizza and Grill

Ernie's Pizzeria

Dayton Street Apizza

Pizza Hut

East Coast Pizza Truck Catering

More Than Pizza

Blake Street Pizza

Pizza Heaven Ii

More Than Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza

Domino's

Casa Bianca Pizza New Haven

New Haven Pizza

Town House Pizza

Blaze Pizza

Kimberly Pizza

Frisco's Pizza

Annex Pizza

Joey D's Pizza Restaurant

Annex Pizza

Grand Apizza New Haven

Quinnipiac Pizza & Deli

Ozzy's Apizza

Pizza Plus

Avelino's Pizza

Andy's Pizza & Restaurant

Sally's Apizza

Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina Napoletana

The Spot

Da Legna at Nolo