New Haven

Best American Restaurants in New Haven

Looking for the best American restaurants in New Haven? We've gathered 30 spots serving American food in New Haven, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best American Restaurants in New Haven

Colony House Restaurant

Richards Restaurant - New Haven,IN

Don Hall's Canal Tap Haus

Don Hall's Restaurants

New Haven Coney Island

Main Street Grill

The Kitchen

Priscilla Lacy presents Woody’s Wings

Bella's Cafe

Woody’s Wings Downtown New Haven

BLDG

Patricia's Restaurant

Box 63 American Bar & Grill

Pierson College Buttery

Heirloom

Crispy Melty by Caseus

John Davenport's Restaurant

Inspired Turkey

The Kitchen Table

Roxbury station kitchen

80 Proof American Kitchen & Bar

Elm City Social

ZINC New Haven

ZINC Modern American Food

Sandra's Next Generation

The Devil's Diet Dessert Bar

Lucky's Star Bus Cafe

WingMadness

Knickerbockers

Kwella's Kitchen

Discover

For restaurants

Company