New Albany

Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

Looking for the best Pizza restaurants in New Albany? We've gathered 45 spots serving Pizza food in New Albany, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

Mimo's Pizzeria

Papa Murphy's

Derby City Pizza

Pizza Hut

Hot Stuff Pizza

Domino's

Dominos of New Albany, Mississippi

District 22 Pizzeria

Parlour

8th Street Pizza

8th Street Pizza

8Th Street Pizza

Spinellis Pizza New Albany

Cosmo’s Craft Pizza

Hunt Brothers Pizza

Hunt Brothers Pizza

Arni's

Rapid Fired Pizza

Chicago City Pizza

Domino's

8th Street Pizza

Papa John's Pizza

Legacy Pizza and Bakery

Papa John's Pizza

Bearno's Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza

Bearno's Pizza

Pizza King

Topp't Pizza

Tony Impellizzeri's Pizza

Jet's Pizza

Zero's Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza

Donatos New Albany North

Mellow Mushroom

Eagles Pizza

Sbarro

Zero's Pizza

Donatos Pizza

Pizza Pit

Fox's Pizza Den

Domino's

Marco's Pizza

Pizza Hut