Middletown

Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

Looking for the best Pizza restaurants in Middletown? We've gathered 152 spots serving Pizza food in Middletown, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

J & J Pizzeria and Grille

Midtown Pizza

Midtown Pizza of Middletown

Domino's

Pats Select Pizza | Grill

Select Pizza and Grill

Singas Famous Pizza

Grotto Pizza

Grotto Pizza

Cuzino's Family Kitchen

Nino's Pizza

Seasons Pizza

Tonys Pizza

La Piazza Italian Restaurant & Grille

Papa Johns Pizza

Roma Pizza

Fox's Pizza Den

Roma Pizza

Pizza Di Napoli

Pizza Di Napoli

Caruso's Bistro

Domino's

SAL ILLIANO

American Mushroom Hunter

Pronto II Pizza And Restaurant

Basilles

Cugini’s Pizzeria

Yovani's Pizza

Mezza Luna Pizzeria

Pecorino's Pizzeria

Michelangelo's

Caputo's Pizzeria

Soprano’s Pizza

Bari Pizza

Domino's Pizza

Bari Pizza and Pasta

Carlos Pizzeria and Bar

Badabing Pizzeria

Badabing Pizzeria

Cugino's

Andolini's

3 Brothers Pizza

3 Brothers Pizzeria

Brother Bruno's Pizzeria

Pellegrino and Sons Pizzeria

Amici Pizzeria & Restaurant

John's Of Arthur Ave

Yani's Pizza

Discover

For restaurants

Company