Middletown

Best Italian Restaurants in Middletown

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Middletown? We've gathered 45 spots serving Italian food in Middletown, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Middletown

Piccolo Cucina e Vino

Toscanella Village Cafe

Pecorino's Pizzeria

Trattoria Toscana

Cosimo's Brick Oven

Fratelli's Italian Seafood

Alfred's Victorian

Alfred's Victorian

Randazzo’s Trattoria

Luna's Pizzeria & Italian Grill

Immediato's Italian Specialties

Fratelli's Italian Specialties

Nana’s Italian Kitchen

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Carabas

Villa Restaurant

Olive Garden

Yovani's Pizza

Carlo’s Cucina Italiana

Badabing Pizzeria

La FATA’s Eatery

Trattoria Locale

Melilli Pizzeria & Catering

Newfield Pizza

Vecchitto's Italian Ice

Luce Restaurant

Esca Restaurant & Wine Bar

Fiore II Restaurant

Amici Italian Grill

Jon's Restaurant

Ninos Restaurant and Bar

Vero Cucino Rustico

Illiano's Ristorante & Pizzeria

Carmela's on the Extension

Avella's and Melilli's Italian Specialty Market and Catering and Pizzeria

Tuscany Grill

Stella D'oro

Bottega Bocconi

First & Last Tavern

Spinning Fork Restaurant

Olive Garden

Italian Touch

Fratelli's of Middletown

Franco Di Roma

Pasquale's Pizzeria III

Discover

For restaurants

Company