Key West

Best American Restaurants in Key West

Looking for the best American restaurants in Key West? We've gathered 36 spots serving American food in Key West, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best American Restaurants in Key West

The Jerk

Grunts

Mr Z's

Turks Back Deck

Firefly Southern Kitchen

Spencer's By The Sea

Onlywood South

Square One

Christopher's at Lateda

Endless Summer Grill

Sunset Pier

Viva Saloon

The Deli Restaurant

Bob's On Margaret

Casa Marina Kitchen

Flaglers Restaurant

Smathers Beach Snack Shack

SHOR Restaurant Key West

Hideaway Grill at Sunset Lounge

Wonder's Burger

The Dirty Pig

Rooftop Cafe

Cero Bodega

Hard Rock Cafe Key West

Thompson Fish House, Turtle Cannery And Kraals

The Galley

Lost Kitchen Key West

LL's Test Kitchen

The Conch Flyer Restaurant & Lounge

Saltwatersandwiches.com

Mangrove Mama's Restaurant

The Blind Pig

US-1

Blackfin Bistro

Fogarty's

Caroline's Cafe

Discover

For restaurants

Company