Islip

Best Italian Restaurants in Islip

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Islip? We've gathered 15 spots serving Italian food in Islip, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Islip

il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante

Angela's Pizzeria

Butera's

Da Noi Italian Restaurant

Nico at the Gatsby Mansion

Delivered Fresh NY

Edesia Restaurant and Pizzeria

Ralph's Italian Ices

Il Piccolo Villaggio

Ralphs Italian Ices of Bayshore

Benedetto's Pizza & Pasta

Americano Pie Bar

Saviano's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Vinnie's Mulberry Street

Mamma Lombardi's Restaurant