Indianapolis

Best American Restaurants in Indianapolis

Looking for the best American restaurants in Indianapolis? We've gathered 243 spots serving American food in Indianapolis, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best American Restaurants in Indianapolis

The Mad Griddle

Chucks Coney Island

Mimi Blue Meatballs

R Bistro

Rooster's Kitchen

Mimi Blue Restaurants

Double Eagle at Scottish Rite

Harrison’s

The Flatiron

Flatiron

Mesh

Owners Wife

The Eagle

The Garden Table (Mass Ave)

Sahm's Tavern

Porter Books And Bread

Famous Steak and Lemonade

The 908 Bar And Grill

120 West Bar & Grill

Great American Grill At The Hilton Garden Inn

The Social American Tavern

The Sanitary Diner

Stars Sandwich Market

Ralph's Great Divide

Natural State Provisions

Buffalo Wild Wings

Mama's

Dunaway's

Cerulean Indianapolis

Bluebeard

Madison's Cafe

Chef JJ's Downtown

Burger Study

Harry & Izzy's

1913 Restaurant

Pullman's Restaurant & Bar

Lightbound Courtside Club

Fire by Henri Najem

Hue Dine

Claypool Grille

Level One

The Eagle's Nest

Johnny Rockets

Sugar Factory - Indianapolis

Steak Escape

14 West

Fat Rooster Diner

Granite City