Columbus

Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Columbus? We've gathered 112 spots serving Italian food in Columbus, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

Carfagna's

Piada Italian Street Food

Piada Italian Street Food

Fazoli's

Olive Garden

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Mabella’s Italian Steakhouse

Trevioli Italian Kitchen North Columbus

Trevioli Artisan Pasta Company

Wood Stone Restaurant

Peluso's Italian Restaurant

Fazoli's

Nana Fritta's

Italian Soul

Peppone’s Ristorante Pizzeria

Guy Fieri's Trattoria

Johnny Carino's

Gabagool

Trevioli Italian Kitchen At The Rapids

Deorio's

CJ's Italian Bistro

Valentinos of Columbus

Fazoli's

Carino's Italian

Johnny Carino's

Bucceto's Pizza Pasta

Tre Bicchieri

Angottis Italian Restaurant

Bella Pizza Company

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Grandma's Pizza & Pasta

Peluso's Italian Restaurant

Smith's Restaurant and Deli

Caffe Davinci

Pasta Villa

Piada Italian Street Food

Lupo

Bravo Italian Kitchen

Lennox

Pelino's Pasta

Trattoria Roma

Z Cucina di Spirito

Z Cucina di Spirito

Italian Village, Columbus, Ohio

Basi Italia

The Rossi Kitchen and Bar

Olive Garden

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant