Eatarian discovery

98 Best Restaurants in Centereach (2026)

We track 98 restaurants in Centereach on Eatarian, from neighbourhood favourites to standout dining rooms. Cuisines here include Mexican and Pizza. Reserve a free table or order direct — no booking fees, ever.

Unclaimed

El Rio Restaurant

Mexican Centereach

Mexican

Unclaimed

Benny's Pizzeria

Pizza Centereach

Pizza

Browse by cuisine

Narrow Centereach down to the cuisine you're craving.

Mexican Pizza