Brookhaven

Best Italian Restaurants in Brookhaven

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Brookhaven? We've gathered 14 spots serving Italian food in Brookhaven, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Brookhaven

Joe's Pizza and Pasta

Vincenzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Fusilli

Vero Pizzeria

Mama Bella's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Cafe Gia

Lombardi's

Bella Maria

Pellegrino's Pizza

Mirko Pasta

La Cecilia

Rocco's Pizzeria and Ristorante

Setauket Pastaria

Pat's Pizza & Pasta

Discover

For restaurants

Company