Bay Shore

Best Pizza Restaurants in Bay Shore

Looking for the best Pizza restaurants in Bay Shore? We've gathered 26 spots serving Pizza food in Bay Shore, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Pizza Restaurants in Bay Shore

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore

Bono's Pizzeria

The Pie at Salvatore's

Amore Pizza

Ginos

Gino's Italian Pizzeria & Restaurant

Victorio II Pizza

Blaze Pizza

The Classic New York Pizza Joint

Elio's Pizzeria

Albert's

Sbarro

Victorio's Pizza

Jerry's

Joe's Pasta & Pizza

The Pizza Corner

Pizza Hut Express

Mama Deluca Pizza

Pizza Hut Express

Bruno's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Valentinos

Pizza Shack of Kismet

Fredy's Pizza & Restaurant

Slice of Bay Shore

Buseto Pizza

Domino's

Discover

For restaurants

Company