Bay Shore

Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Bay Shore? We've gathered 10 spots serving Italian food in Bay Shore, ranked by real diner reviews and ratings. Browse photos, check menus, and request a free reservation — all in one place. Updated June 2026.

Unclaimed

Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Fratelli Pizzeria

Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

Pie At Salvatore's

Perfect Pasta and Gelato ~ Italian CafÃ¨

La Picada Catering

La Casa Pizza & Pasta

Tina's II

Ita Kitchen

Mama Safia's Pizza & Restaurant

Mulberry Street Bay Shore